Obamacare Unlocks American Innovation

innovationAmerica’s antiquated health care insurance system has hampered innovation and ultimately slowed economic growth for decades due to the insurance system’s perverse incentives. However, the 2010 Affordable Care Act (ACA), or Obamacare, has done much to reverse those disincentives. Consider the following scenario:

Imagine you work for a large company that pays an acceptable salary. Like three-fifths of all American workers, your employer also pays a significant portion of your family’s health insurance premium, which, as part of a group health insurance plan, already costs much less compared to the health plans available to small businesses and the self-employed. However, after working at the same company for many years, you yearn for the opportunity to start your own business. Maybe you are tired of being subordinate to a large corporate bureaucracy. Perhaps you have even begun to hate your job. Over time, you develop a several good business ideas and finally are at a point where you feel your proposals are robust enough to start a new business. What would keep you from quitting a job you do not like for pursuing your personal business dream? Like any responsible breadwinner, if the job was your family’s sole source of health insurance coverage, you would likely be hesitant to give that up in order to start a new business without any guarantee of success.

Starting a new business is precarious enough, without having to worry about the risk of financial ruin by dropping your health coverage. Economists call this phenomenon “job lock,” a situation where individuals feel they are locked into their job for fear of losing health coverage for their families. That fear is not unfounded because prior to the Great Recession in 2008, the number one cause of personal bankruptcy in the U.S. was medical expenses. Uninsured and underinsured families who suffered serious illness often went broke trying to keep up with medical bills. According to a survey conducted by the Employee Benefit Research Institute, 27 percent of workers reported that their employee health benefits were the primary reason they would not change jobs or retire.

The trouble with job lock is that it greatly impedes innovation and ingenuity. Economists across the political spectrum agree that development of new technologies is a primary driver of economic growth. Our nation needs more people to innovate and start new businesses in order to achieve and maintain robust economic growth. Through its health insurance exchanges and expanded Medicaid coverage, ACA offers more affordable health insurance coverage options to millions of American workers, giving workers greater control over their future, thereby reducing the power of job lock.

ACA’s detractors have used a recent report from the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) about ACA and its impact on employment levels to assert that health care reform law will hurt the economy by increasing unemployment. Critics base this claim on a CBO estimate, which predicts that ACA will lead to a reduction in the amount of hours workers choose to work, equivalent to 2.5 million workers over 10 years. However, the CBO report was primarily an analysis of ACA’s impact on the supply of labor. As the report stated, “the estimated reduction stems almost entirely from a net decline in the amount of labor that workers choose to supply, rather than from a net drop in businesses’ demand for labor.” Contrary to many popular claims, the CBO report did not find that unemployment would increase as a result of ACA. To the contrary, the report indicated that ACA would “boost overall demand for goods and services over the next few years because the people who will benefit from the expansion of Medicaid and from access to the exchange subsidies are predominantly in lower-income households and thus are likely to spend a considerable fraction of their additional resources on goods and services.” This “will in turn boost demand for labor over the next few years.” In other words, ACA will actually reduce unemployment.

In essence, the CBO report reveals that ACA will deliver a powerful blow against innovation-obstructing job lock. Elderly workers who are in a job simply for the insurance until they are old enough to qualify for Medicare now have more flexibility for an early retirement. New mothers will have greater flexibility to reduce their hours or stay home with their small children, should they so choose. Other workers may elect to reduce their hours to care for an ailing family member. And perhaps most significantly for our economy, some workers can now go part-time or quit their jobs altogether as they prepare to launch new business ventures. The CBO report simply confirms that Americans can expect greater flexibility to pursue their desires and dreams as ACA is fully implemented.

Print Friendly
The following two tabs change content below.

Aaron

Author / Editor at MormonDems
I have been an active Latter-Day Saint all of my life and have also been an enthusiastic Democrat and progressive since my days as an economics undergraduate student at Brigham Young University. The hostile climate towards progressives at BYU inspired me to get involved with the BYU College Democrats, where I served as president during my senior year. I have since obtained a master’s degree in international relations from the University of Oklahoma. I served a full-time mission to the Philippines. I’m active in my local ward, happily married and have two rambunctious little boys and an infant daughter.

3 Responses to Obamacare Unlocks American Innovation

  1. howitis says:

    Thank you so much! I have been telling everyone I know that this is one of the greatest advantages of the Affordable Care Act, but it doesn’t get nearly enough attention or publicity. And the way the media played up the story as “OMG Obamacare is going to cause unemployment and make people not wanna work OMG OMG” is downright disgraceful.

    “Job Lock” is a terrible thing; I’ve lived it. I spent years working for a horrible bully of a boss in a corporate job that I loathed, because I needed the health insurance that job provided (I have a rare chronic health condition too complex to discuss here), and I had no other way to get it because of my “preexisting condition.” It was spirit-crushing. I knew others in similar situations before the ACA. A friend had a great idea for a new business but couldn’t leave his job to start it, because his son had epilepsy and they couldn’t get health insurance for him. A coworker nearing retirement wanted to cut her work hours and help care for her grandchildren, but couldn’t because she was a cancer survivor who couldn’t get health insurance, was too young for Medicare, and couldn’t afford the outrageous COBRA premiums.

    The ACA has allowed me to get out from under crushing ($800/month) COBRA costs; I was laid off last year, and thanks to the ACA I now have a policy with benefits identical to the one my company provided, with premiums that are HALF of what I was being charged for COBRA (and that is without any tax subsidy, thank you very much!!!) I am now doing freelance work and working part-time for a small non-profit organization, and am much happier than I ever was in the corporate world.

    Seriously, would it really be a horrible thing if the ACA allows some people to retire early from their jobs because they no longer have to wait for Medicare? Of if more parents quit their jobs or cut their hours so they could devote more time to being parents, thanks to coverage through the ACA? (I thought the party of “family values” wanted more parents–especially women–to stay home and take care of their children?!?) And I agree with you that somewhere out there is a person who just might be the next Bill Gates, who has been “job locked” for years in a corporate cubicle, and now will be free to start a new business and create some jobs of his own. Seems to me that the ACA will actually free up jobs that can now perhaps be filled by some of our long-term unemployed, who desperately need them. And if companies are worried that employees, no longer dependent on their employers for health insurance, will start quitting their jobs en masse thanks to the ACA, well maybe that just means employers will have to find other ways to keep their employees. (You know, like maybe treating their employees like human beings, instead of another resource to use up and throw away? Just a thought….)

    Anyway. Thank you again. I am not a Mormon (or even a Christian), but I love your blog. Keep up the good work!

    • Aaron says:

      Thank you very much for taking the time to comment. It’s great to get this kind of feedback from someone who has experienced the phenomenon discussed in the article. I think it’s pretty clear to most people that the pre-ACA health care system was a burden on individuals and on the economy as a whole. And ACA’s net-positive impact on our country would be clearer if there wasn’t such a massive disinformation campaign against it.

  2. What a fantastic, well-articulated piece. Thank you Aaron! Here’s my own very personal reason why ACA is important to my family – a formerly “uninsurable” child. 🙂 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/graciela-tiscarenosato/supreme-court-aca-premature-children_b_1649900.html

    Keep up the great work!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *